Category Archives: Uncategorized

The Apollo 13 Mission and Rescue: How much plutonium was added to the Earth’s environment?

By Jay T. Cullen

The purpose of this short post is to compare the relative amounts of radioactive plutonium released to our environment from the Apollo 13 mission in April 1970 and the

1280px-Apollo_13-insignia.png
Apollo 13 mission patch/emblem with a depiction of the Greek god of the Sun and latin phrase “Ex Luna, Scientia” which means “From the Moon, Knowledge.”

Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant disaster that began in March 2011.  Apollo 13 was the third mission planned to bring American astronauts to land on the moon and conduct scientific studies there.  On April 11 1970 the Saturn V rocket carrying astronauts James Lovell (Commander), Fred Haise (Lunar Module Pilot) and Jack Swigert (Command Module Pilot) was launched from the Kennedy Space Center in Florida.

The mission plan was to land Lovell and Haise in the Fra Mauro highland area of the moon but, due to unforeseen circumstances, that never came to pass.  As many of you know as was popularized in the 1995 film directed by Ron Howard and starring Tom Hanks (Lovell), the late Bill Paxton (Haise) and Kevin Bacon (Swigert) the lunar landing was aborted after a malfunction in one of the service module oxygen tanks caused an explosion that crippled the spacecraft.

Apollo_13_Service_Module_-_AS13-59-8500.jpeg
Photo of the damaged Service Module taken shortly after it was jettisoned by the Apollo 13 crew.

What followed was a technical problem solving masterpiece to bring the astronauts safely back to Earth with limited power and life support systems. The rescue of Lovell, Haise and Swigert has been characterized as a “successful failure” and NASA’s finest hour.

Plutonium in the Environment from Apollo 13

A consequence of not having landed on the moon was that the descent stage of the Lunar Module (LM; which would normally have brought Lovell and Haise down to the surface and been left behind when they returned) was now being brought back to Earth.  The power and life support afforded by the LM was central to the successful rescue of the crew.  What is significant about this is that the power supply attached to the descent stage of the LM to be left on the lunar surface to provide electric power for the Apollo Lunar Surface Experiment Packages (ALSEP) was a SNAP-27 Radioisotope Thermal Generator (RTG) containing 1,650 TBq (TBq = 1012 Becquerel) or roughly 3.9 kilograms of plutonium oxide fuel.  While the RTG was essential to bring astronauts home safely the high velocity reentry of the LM raised the possibility of contaminating the atmosphere and surface Earth with worrying amounts of Pu.  To avoid the possibility of the RTG coming down in a populated area the flight engineers had the LM enter the Earth’s atmosphere such that the RTG would be deposited in the remote Pacific Ocean near the Tonga Trench where water depth is about 6-9 kilometers.  Measurements in the atmosphere and ocean following the reentry of the LM suggested that the RTG had survived intact and little of the Pu was broadcast in the environment.  Tests of the RTG casing suggest that this 3.9 kg of Pu, somewhere on the seafloor of the Pacific, will not be mobilized for another ~800 years.
https://www.facebook.com/plugins/post.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2FFlightOfApollo%2Fposts%2F1121563224620322%3A0&width=500

Plutonium Released From Fukushima

The triple meltdown and hydrogen explosions at the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant (FDNPP) are known to have released some of FDNPP Pu isotope inventory to the environment.  Direct measurements of air, water and soil and modeling of the temperature and pressure in the reactors during the meltdowns by the international scientific community have allowed the total amount of Pu broadcast to the environment during the period of peak releases in the weeks to month following the disaster. These direct measurements made globally, the models and comparisons with isotopes that were released in much greater quantities (e.g. 137-Cesium and 131-Iodine) indicate that about 2.3 x 109 Bq or about 580 milligrams of Pu left the FDNPP in the wake of the disaster.  This is about 700,000 fold less Pu than Apollo 13’s RTG.  While the Apollo 13 Pu is likely to have little environmental impact given that it will be released slowly to the deep ocean over time I think it is interesting to compare the total amounts given the perceived impact of the FDNPP releases.  Both the FDNPP and Apollo 13 Pu are dwarfed by the ~11 PBq (PBq = 1015 Bq) of Pu-239,240 released to the atmosphere as a result of nuclear weapons testing in the 20th century.

Advertisements

Fukushima contamination of Pacific Salmon: Lessons learned in the Atlantic Ocean

By Jay T. Cullen

atlanticsalmon
Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)

The purpose of this post is to present measurements of artificial radionuclides in wild Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) made in 1990’s and reported in a peer reviewed paper published in the Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences by Tucker and colleagues in 1999. This post is part of an ongoing series dedicated to communicating the results of scientific research aimed at The paper combines an understanding of bioconcentration of the artificial radionuclide 137-cesium (137Cs half life ~30 years) in marine food webs with quality measurements of the contaminant in salmon that spent their lives in the North Atlantic Ocean.  The North Atlantic at the time had a strong east to west gradient in 137Cs concentrations in seawater with >10 Bq m-3 in the east owing to spent nuclear fuel reprocessing in Europe and the recent impact of the Chernobyl disaster and <1.5 Bq m-3 in the west near to Canada.  Salmon returning to the Ste. Marguerite River in Canada had a wide range of radiocesium in their bodies which reflected the entire range of values seen in fish harvested across the Atlantic Ocean.  The results indicate that the migration routes of these salmon extended all the way across the Atlantic to the Irish and Norwegian seas.  The study is relevant to understanding the impact of the Fukushima disaster on radiocesium levels in Pacific salmon as the maximum levels of contamination of seawater we see in the central and eastern North Pacific is lower than the maximum levels studies by Tucker and colleagues.  Given this fact we would predict that levels of Fukushima derived contaminants in Pacific salmon and the health risk associated with the consumption of these fish will be correspondingly lower.  Thus far the salmon monitoring results from the Integrated Fukushima Ocean Radionuclide Monitoring (InFORM) project are in keeping with the scientific communities understanding of 137Cs bioconcentration in fish outlined in the Tucker study and references therein.


Radionuclides in Atlantic Salmon: Bioconcentration and migration routes

When I was an undergraduate student at McGill University in Montreal, Dr. Joe Rasmussen (he is now at the University of Lethbridge in Alberta) headed up a freshwater ecology group that used radionuclides to understand energy and contaminant cycling in the aquatic environment. I remember learning about gamma spectrometry and the processing of samples for radionuclide determinations through conversations with his graduate students.  Their work made an impression on me and highlighted the utility of radioisotopes for understanding rates of processes and pathways of contaminant transport in natural waters.  The paper I will summarize here roughly dates to my time at McGill and is the work of Strahan Tucker who along with Marc Trudel works for Fisheries and Oceans Canada at the Pacific Biological Station in Nanaimo BC and part of the team of scientists working on the InFORM project.  Tucker and colleagues exploited the east to west gradient in 137Cs activity in seawater in the North Atlantic to determine how much radiocesium was present in Atlantic salmon returning to the Ste. Marguerite River in Canada and by extension where they had migrated and fed during their growth and development.  The figure below shows the high levels of seawater 137Cs contamination in the Irish Sea and eastern Atlantic compared to the western Atlantic near Canada owing to release of the isotope from fuel reprocessing plants in the UK and France and deposit of Chernobyl derived contamination in 1986.

Fig1Tuckeretal1999

137Cs distribution (Bq m–3) in waters of the North Atlantic with levels >10 in marginal seas of the eastern Atlantic and 0-1.5 in waters of the west near to Canada.

Given that salmon tend to bioconcentrate radiocesium about 130 times relative to the seawater in which the live (through the prey they consume) the predicted range in 137Cs in salmon from the eastern Atlantic would be 1.3 — 4.0 Bq kg-1 while fish living in the less contaminated western Atlantic would have 0.15 — 0.65 Bq kg-1.  The range of 137Cs measured by Tucker and colleagues in salmon returning to the St. Marguerite River in Quebec, Canada, predicted ranges given seawater activities in the figure above and activities in fish harvested from different areas of the North Atlantic are summarized in the figure below.

Fig1bTuckeretal1999

Frequency distribution of 137Cs concentrations (Bq kg–1) in Atlantic salmon from the Ste. Marguerite River, Que. Tissue samples were obtained fish caught in the sport fishery during the summers of 1995 (n = 33) and 1996 (n = 28) and measured by gamma spectrometry. Dashed vertical lines denote the expected range in 137Cs concentrations in salmon based on a mean bioaccumulation factor of 130 from waters in the North Atlantic outlined in the color bar above (water 137Cs concentrations color coded as in the first figure). Horizontal lines denote the observed ranges in 137Cs concentrations in salmon and other fish (cod, whiting, haddock, hake, mackerel, and plaice) caught in those same waters.

The range of activities found in the migratory Atlantic salmon is similar to the range seen for other species of fish across the North Atlantic and suggests that almost half of the Ste. Marguerite salmon spent their lives feeding in waters near to Norway and the UK.  This is an amazing result and suggested that more fish spend more time in the eastern Atlantic than was thought at the time.  The levels seen in the salmon agree well with predictions based on seawater activities and the expected bioconcentration factor in the food web to salmon of ~130.  You can read more about bioconcentration of radionuclides and concentration factors in marine organisms in one of my earlier posts here.

What does this tell us about expected contamination from Fukushima in Pacific Salmon and health risks to consumers?

The maximum seawater concentration of 137Cs in the central and eastern North Pacific we have measured through the InFORM project is about 7 — 10 Bq m-3. Given the bioconcentration expected from previous studies of salmonid species like Tucker and colleagues above we might expect maximum contamination levels in Pacific salmon of ~ 1.3 Bq kg-1 wet weight.  The range of values we have detected in Pacific species returning to British Columbia rivers and streams since the Fukushima disaster in 2011 is ~0.20-0.60 Bq kg-1 suggesting that these fish have consumed prey and lived in waters with seawater activities <10 Bq m-3.  At present the levels of Fukushima derived contamination do not lead to ionizing radiation doses to consumers that remotely approach the dose attributable to naturally occurring radioisotopes like 40K and 210Po.  The ionizing radiation dose from the naturally occurring isotopes do not approach levels where significant risks to the health of consumers are to be expected.  Given what the scientific community understands about bioconcentration of the most radiologically significant isotopes released from Fukushima and measured and forecast levels of these isotopes in the expansive North Pacific the community has confidence that levels in Pacific salmon species will not approach levels were risk to consumers will become significant. The InFORM project will continue to monitor contamination levels in seawater and the marine biota to provide accurate information and useful, scientifically derived assessment of risk to the public.